14,000+ results for colour eye pencil
- Estee Lauder Double Wear Stay-in-Place Eye Pencil Full Size-Color is SMOKEOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$15.00Free shipping89 soldSave up to 15% when you buy moreren-syler (41) 97.4%
- L'Oreal Pencil Perfect Automatic Eye Liner Metallic Pewter Beauty Make Up.01 ozOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$5.79Was: $8.2730% offFree shipping4 watchersSave up to 20% when you buy moredealsallday1-9 (129) 99.2%
- JORDANA EASYLINE FOR EYE RETRACTABLE PENCIL COLOR: CREAMY COCOAOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$18.49Free shipping122 solddew-rain (985) 97.2%
- Styli-Style Flat Eye Pencil - You Choose ColorOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$9.99Free shippingFree returnsSave up to 6% when you buy moreTop Rated Plushigherbeautyplus (29,782) 99.4%
- NYX MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil Choose ColorOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$7.99 to $11.99Free 2-3 day shippingFree returns175+ sold10% off 2+ with couponmadison-ave-deals (150,596) 99.4%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Multi-Use Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner PencilOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$8.81List price: $19.9956% offFree 1-3 day shippingFree returnsSave up to 7% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusdesignerbrandsforless (103,593) 97.6%
- Kleancolor Smoky Smudgy Eyeliner Eye Pencil Choose Your Color Buy 2 Get 3rd FreeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$5.23Free 2-4 day shippingFree returnsBuy 2, get 1 freestuff4youplus (9,538) 99.4%
- Original Maybelline Expert Eyes Brow & Eye Pencil (Select Color) New UnboxOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$5.95 to $29.95Free shippingFree returns49+ soldTop Rated Plusfragranceandbeauty (13,592) 99.6%
Picked For You
Sponsored | Top selling items from highly rated sellers with free shipping- 1 NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Eyeshadow "Pick Your 1 Color" *Joy's cosmetics*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$4.95 to $9.99+$4.60 shippingFree returns52+ soldSave up to 10% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusjoy017 (124,437) 99.8%
- 1 NYX Slim Eye Pencil / Eyeliner - SPE "Pick Your 1 Color" *Joy's cosmetics*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$4.55 to $9.99+$4.60 shippingFree returns58+ soldSave up to 10% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusjoy017 (124,437) 99.8%
- (Set of 6 pencils SET) NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil Set SEJEP01.Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.99Free 2-4 day shipping21 watchersSave up to 20% when you buy morecookies567 (15,633) 99.6%
- NOS **Avon Big Color EXTRA Eye Pencil / CRAYON YOU CHOOSE ** Factory SealedOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.99Free shippingjeanabc (2,603) 100%
- Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil Set 20 Colors Long Lasting Matte Crème Gel Eye LinersOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$13.99Free 2-4 day shippingFree returns973 soldSave up to 7% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusgameinfinity (342,088) 98.7%
- M.A.C. Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner HELL-BENT - Size 0.35 g / 0.01 Oz NIBOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$16.99Free shippingFree returnsSave up to 15% when you buy moreceris_industries (2,285) 98.3%
- JORDANA EASYLINE FOR EYE RETRACTABLE PENCIL COLOR: CREAMY COCOA SEALED.Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$18.99Free shipping71 soldSave up to 15% when you buy morestarry* (426) 97.5%
- 2X 12 Color Glitter Eyeshadow Lip EyeLiner Eye Shadow Pencil Shimmer Pen MakeupOpens in a new window or tabBrand New74 product ratings - 2X 12 Color Glitter Eyeshadow Lip EyeLiner Eye Shadow Pencil Shimmer Pen Makeup$11.99Free shippingFree returns398 soldSave up to 20% when you buy morekimssuperdeals (4,487) 100%
- Cargo SWIMMABLES EYE LINER Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner U PICK COLOR Full Size BOXOpens in a new window or tabBrand New4 product ratings - Cargo SWIMMABLES EYE LINER Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner U PICK COLOR Full Size BOX$9.99Free 2-3 day shippingFree returns103+ soldBuy 1, get 1 25% offTop Rated Plusfastbeauty2u (85,614) 99.7%
- 2 CoverGirl Perfect Blend Eye Pencil (Choose Your Color)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.99Free shippingshaba-7084 (30) 100%
- AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon BLUE SMOKE (B602) 1.6 g net wt 0.056 oz *NEW*Opens in a new window or tabNew without box$18.87Free shipping3 watchersedwar-low (2,067) 99.3%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil - RustOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.79Free shippingvibrantandvogue (869) 99.5%
- Lancome EyeLiner Pencil Le Crayon Khol, Le Stylo, Color Design choose shadeOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$12.99 to $29.99+$5.55 shippingpapayafruit (64,609) 99.4%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil - CottageOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.00Free shippingvibrantandvogue (869) 99.5%
- L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil - Eyeshadow Pencil - Highly Pigmented - *13 SHADES*Opens in a new window or tabNew without box$2.00+$4.26 shippingFree returnsTop Rated Pluschikabellas (3,304) 96.2%
- Avon Big Color Eye Pencil, Natural Vibe, New & SealedOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$8.00Free shippinggolfcoursejunkie (388) 100%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil - IcedOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$5.82Free shippingvibrantandvogue (869) 99.5%
- NEW Maybelline Expert Wear Twin Brow and Eye Pencils Select your color*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$7.90 to $12.99Free shipping37+ soldezdea-37 (3,595) 97%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Precision Dual Ended Seamless Blending Eyebrow PencilOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$13.98List price: $19.9930% offFree 1-3 day shippingFree returnsSave up to 7% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusdesignerbrandsforless (103,593) 97.6%
- MAC COLOUR EXCESS Gel Pencil Eye Liner ~Glide or Die~ .01oz .35g *READ DETAILS*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.50Free shippingelisbeltr-0 (1,512) 100%
- MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner - Hell-Bent .35g New In BoxOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$17.99Free 2-4 day shippingLast one7 watchersyuka-hash (4,329) 99.3%
- PUR EYE PENCIL EYE DEFINING COLOUR PERIDOT .01 OZOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$15.00Was: $18.7520% offFree shippingFree returnsSave up to 9% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusallworldofluxury2018 (8,835) 99.1%
- MAKEUP FOREVER ARTIST LINER - Gliding Eye Pencil-PICK COLOROpens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.00+$4.36 shippingrandomgoodsuneed (909) 100%
- MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner * Hell Bent/Dark Teal Gray* New in BoxOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$16.50Free shippingFree returnsSave up to 15% when you buy moreTop Rated Pluslynnjin (18,468) 100%
- NYX SLIM EYE AND EYEBROW PENCIL ALL COLORS (SPE901-940) - YOU PICK !!Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$8.99 to $10.99Free shippingaboutbeauty678 (7,983) 98.9%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil Choose ColorOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$7.25Free shippingyoucanlookgreat (33,759) 99%
- L.A. COLORS Eyeliner Pencil - Smooth Formula - Accentuates Eyes - *TURQUOISE*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$1.99+$4.26 shippingFree returnsTop Rated Pluschikabellas (3,304) 96.2%
- LA Colors Brow Pencil Eyebrow Pencil ~ Soft Brown #CBBP346 ~ SEALEDOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$3.79Free shipping147777 (113) 100%
- Styli-Style Flat Eye Pencil - You Choose ColorOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.50Free shippingFree returns11+ soldTop Rated Plusxscosmetics (81,898) 98.7%
- E.L.F. Brow Pencil (Dual-Tip) | Fills & Shapes | Choose Your ShadeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$4.99Free shippingSave up to 7% when you buy moresheneedsall (2) 100%
- Make Up Forever Artist Color Pencil 612 Dimensional Dark BrownOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$23.99+$3.96 shipping17 soldusnat-qxdychen (693) 98.8%
- Waterproof Microblading Eye Brow Eyeliner Eyebrow Pen Pencil Brush Makeup ToolOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$0.99Free shippingfrom ChinaFree returns401+ soldclassictop797 (4,044) 97.8%
- Eyebrow Pencil Microblading Tattoo Waterproof Fork Tip 3D Makeup Ink 4 fork PenOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$2.48Free shippingallinone20231 (1,626) 97.9%
- MAC : Eye Pencil/Liner Assortment ***BEST PRICES***-100% Authentic- devoncpbOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$10.00 to $14.00+$5.25 shipping26+ soldSave up to 6% when you buy moredevoncpb (1,627) 99.1%
- MAC COLOUR EXCESS Gel Pencil Eye Liner Glide or Die .01oz .35g Full Size ~ NIBOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.00+$3.96 shippingSave up to 10% when you buy moremaz_reselling (15) 100%
- MAC colour excess gel pencil eye liner (Pool Shark) (.01 OZ.)*READ DETAILSOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$18.50Free 2-4 day shippingelisbeltr-0 (1,512) 100%
- Mary Kay Second Look Eye Pencil - Choose Your Color - New Old StockOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$8.99Was: $14.9940% off+$4.00 shippingFree returnsSave up to 20% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusunit626_2 (762) 99.8%
- CLARINS CRAYON KOHL LONG-LASTING EYE PENCIL - CHOOSE YOUR COLOR !!Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$15.99Was: $19.9920% offFree shipping18+ soldSave up to 20% when you buy morecadl_29 (552) 98.8%
- CHANEL INTENSE EYE PENCIL #61 NOIR & ROUGE ALLURE LIP COLOUROpens in a new window or tabBrand New$17.000 bids · Time left4d 10h left (Sun, 11:28 AM)+$7.00 shippingoral437 (1,164) 100%
- new AVON Big Color Eye Pencil crayon liner eyeshadow - night glistenOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$21.47Free 2-3 day shippingFree returnsavonenvy (12,885) 99.7%
- Osmosis Beauty Colour Eye Pencil Eye Liner, Navy 0.04 Oz. Full Size, New SealedOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$27.59Was: $34.4920% offFree shippingLast onemystiqueglowbeauty (640) 100%
- Kleancolor Retractable Lip Eye Liner Waterproof Pick From 28 Colors B2Get1FreeOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$5.71Free 2-4 day shippingFree returns152+ soldBuy 2, get 1 freestuff4youplus (9,538) 99.4%
- Tresluce Gel Color Pencil Intenso Liner Eyeliner Viva .04 oz NewOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$10.99Free shippingtrendy_again (36) 94.4%
- Charlotte Tilbury Eyeliner Pillow Talk Eye Pencil Liner CHOOSE COLOROpens in a new window or tabBrand New$24.00Free shippingpeluche_32 (501) 97.9%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Mechanical Retractable Eyeliner Pencil PICK YOUR COLOROpens in a new window or tabBrand New$7.31 to $14.38Free shipping22+ soldvanegoods-8 (967) 98.9%
- Mac Colour Color Excess Gel Pencil Eye Liner Crayon Lim Ed - GOLD GOALS -FS NWOBOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$12.95Free shippingLast one3 watcherswe3_sell_stuff (6,887) 99.2%
- ( 3 pencils ) Italia Deluxe Ultrafine Pencil Eye / Lip liner - Pick your Color!Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$3.49+$3.45 shippingikindo (15,441) 99.4%
- Etude House Drawing Eye Brow 0.25g Tattoo Pen Pencil Marker 7 Color [US Seller]Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.40 to $6.98Free shippingFree returns114+ soldSave up to 10% when you buy morek-beautyclub (11,411) 98.6%
- MAKE UP FOR EVER ARTIST COLOR PENCIL 500 BOUNDLESS BISQUE .04 OZ / 1.41 G SEALEDOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$14.90Free shippingLast one1 watchersSave up to 20% when you buy morelilamyg817 (897) 100%
- Artist Color Pencil: Eye, Lip & Brow PencilOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$25.00 to $28.50+$6.95 shippingFree returnsecosmeticsofficial (1,249) 96.8%
- Make Up For Ever Artist Color Pencil Brow Eye & Lip Liner Pick 1 NewOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$25.20 to $26.99Was: $29.0010% off+$5.25 shipping6+ soldfioccodineveforever (7,943) 99.6%
- CITY COLOR Photo Eyeliner Pencil Chic ~ CHOOSE YOUR COLOR *SEALED*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$4.99Free 2-4 day shippingFree returnsSave up to 35% when you buy moremommydezarn (42,639) 100%
- NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP MULTI-USE Jumbo Eye Pencil Eyeshadow & Eyeliner SEALEDOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$8.99Free shippingSave up to 10% when you buy morebeautifiedglam (2,285) 98.3%
- Maybelline New York Expert Eyes Twin Brow and Eye Pencils, YOU CHOOSE COLOR NEWOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$11.86 to $12.71Was: $13.9515% offFree 2-4 day shippingFree returnsSave up to 20% when you buy moreTop Rated Plususabeautyplus (36,867) 98.4%
- Avon ColorTrend Eye Define Pencil | Eye Liner-Various Colors to CHOOSE & COMBINEOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$9.95Free shippingSave up to 20% when you buy morenjnewyork (5,647) 98.9%
- ❤️NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil, Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Pencil Jep641Opens in a new window or tabNew without box$6.99Free shippingchil2822 (6,857) 99.5%
- NYX Slim Eye / Eyebrow Pencil color SPE908 Seafoam GreenOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$8.00Free 2-4 day shippingSave up to 15% when you buy moresteals_deals_us (16,135) 99.2%
- Avon Big Color Eye Pencil -Berry 0.056 oz (Bin M)Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$1.99+$5.15 shipping3 watchersmodernexchangellc (102) 100%
- CoverGirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil | Choose Cover Girl Color | Cover Girl |Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.50 to $6.88+$0.99 shipping63+ soldSave up to 15% when you buy moreworkingba9to5 (1,065) 100%
- NYX Cosmetics Jumbo Eyeshadow Eye PencilOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$1.99 to $2.99+$5.55 shippingFree returns102+ soldcosmos201097 (9,409) 100%
- New Sealed City Color Photo Chic Crayon Eyeliner Pencil NAKED Free ShippingOpens in a new window or tabNew without box$3.55Free shippingLast one6 sold2outta3aintbad (819) 98.2%
- LUXVISAGE Long-Lasting BROW PENCIL light eyebrows, Natural ColorsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$9.99Free shippingFree returnsSave up to 20% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusconteamerica (3,106) 99.3%
- L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil - Eyeshadow Pencil - Black Shade - *SUNGLASSES*Opens in a new window or tabBrand New$7.49Free 2-4 day shippingSave up to 20% when you buy morejodiealison (15,696) 99.4%
- NYX Jumbo Eye Pencil eyeliner/shadow. Buy 2 or more 20% Off!!Opens in a new window or tabNew without box$4.45 to $4.99+$4.26 shipping30+ soldSave up to 15% when you buy morel_y_n_s (4,034) 100%
- Microblading Eyebrow Pen Waterproof Fork Tip Tattoo Long Last Eyebrow PencilOpens in a new window or tabSame Day Shipping From SC , buy 1 get 1 FREEBrand New$5.99 to $7.99Free 2-4 day shippingBuy 1, get 1 freejiyuus8 (80,500) 97.6%
- PACK OF 2 YOUNGBLOOD Mineral Cosmetics Intense Color Eye Pencil Passion ColorOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$11.89Was: $13.9915% offFree shippingFree returnsSave up to 15% when you buy moreTop Rated Plusgoodsnyc (251) 100%
- 6 Colors Chameleons Liquid Eyeshadow Color Eye Makeup Face Gel Eyeliner PencilsOpens in a new window or tabBrand New$6.84 to $7.54Free shippingfrom Chinaspen13tne (3,103) 92.5%
- Items Per Page